I largely agree with this review, which also snaps into focus a few things that I hadn't fully articulated (the relative failures of Captain America; the surprising success of the Hulk). I'd thought from the trailer that Cap's adaptation to modern times was going to be the focus and the other characters supporting cast; instead it was an ensemble piece that was amazingly successful at giving every character their chance to shine.

However, I still hold out for The Incredibles as the best superhero movie ever made.