kennahijja, who is a nice person but a fanatic nevertheless, thinks I am a right-wing extremist. marycatelli, who is decidedly not nice and still a fanatic, thinks I am a dangerous socialist with gulags up my sleeve.
"I'm pissing off both sides; therefore I'm an indepedent thinker!" is usually evidence of cognitive dissonance, not independent thinking. E.g., pro-life libertarians, Log Cabin Republicans, etc.
In your case, though, you're a pretty standard European Catholic. The cognitive dissonance comes from your (American) detractors, who are confused, because right now in the U.S., it's impossible to be a social conservative and not also believe that the government is evil and public health care, in particular, is a secret plan to kill old people and put abortion clinics in middle schools.
kennahijja is a German from Swabia, which makes your analysis somewhat hasty. Incidentally, she is the finest fanfic writer I have ever read - better even than you - and if you have not read her work, I double urge you to.
P.S.: I am also at odds in various ways with most Italian Catholics I know on the net.
no subject
Date: 2009-10-21 06:59 pm (UTC)In your case, though, you're a pretty standard European Catholic. The cognitive dissonance comes from your (American) detractors, who are confused, because right now in the U.S., it's impossible to be a social conservative and not also believe that the government is evil and public health care, in particular, is a secret plan to kill old people and put abortion clinics in middle schools.
no subject
Date: 2009-10-21 07:07 pm (UTC)P.S.: I am also at odds in various ways with most Italian Catholics I know on the net.