Another fleeting thought

[fpb]

France, and to a lesser extent Germany, lay claim to the eighteenth-century Enlightenment as to a kind of national treasure and heritage; and the rest of the West tends to agree. Yet those elements of the Enlightenment that had a permanent, positive and enduring impact on the West came neither from Paris nor from the university towns of Germany, but from Edinburgh (Adam Smith's The Wealth of Nations), Milan (Cesare Beccaria's Crimes and Penalties) and from the fledgling, English-speaking United States of America. No work of any French or German author, not even Voltaire or Kant, compares.

Comments

[fpb.livejournal.com]

The derivation of Hegel from Kant is a matter of debate - Popper, for one, saw it as Hegelians co-opting Kant in their own tradition when he really had nothing to do with them. And even if that were not the case, would you call Hegelism and its derivates a positive and constructive element in Western history?

[joetexx.livejournal.com]

Positive and constructive? No. Long lasting, yes. Permanent and enduring - I hope not.